# Legal AI comparison scorecard

An editable evaluation aid from Judicio. This is not a vendor ranking or a legal opinion.
Use the same approved matter, instructions and acceptance criteria for every tool.

## Trial record

- Reviewer and role:
- Trial date:
- Product / version / plan:
- Jurisdiction, court and relevant date:
- Included source collections:
- Sample documents and versions:
- Approved data classification and upload permission:
- Expected tasks per month and number of seats:

## Set acceptance criteria before the trial

| Check | Required result | Observed result / evidence | Pass, fail or unresolved |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Required authorities found | | | |
| Missing / inaccessible authorities recorded | | | |
| Quotation and pinpoint support the proposition | | | |
| Applicable version / subsequent treatment checked | | | |
| Draft preserves supplied facts | | | |
| Missing facts identified rather than invented | | | |
| Defined terms and instructions remain consistent | | | |
| Checklist issues found in body, schedules and amendments | | | |
| False positives and missed issues recorded | | | |
| Suggested wording checked by reviewer | | | |
| Export opens correctly in the team's editor | | | |
| Source record can be reopened or exported | | | |
| Sharing permissions suit the matter | | | |

## Review effort

- Time to prepare inputs:
- Time to generate:
- Time to verify sources:
- Time to correct and approve the final work:
- Correct findings / expected findings (show denominator):
- False positives (describe each):
- Serious unresolved errors:

Avoid percentages from tiny trials without the underlying counts. Repeat a surprising
result and record what changed; do not quietly replace the original observation.

## Commercial and procurement record

| Item | Current written terms / evidence | Open question |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Seats, currency, tax and minimum term | | |
| Source collections and workflow entitlements | | |
| Usage allowances, overages and upload costs | | |
| Integrations and export formats | | |
| Support and onboarding | | |
| Data handling, retention and deletion | | |
| Access controls and relevant assurance evidence | | |
| Exit and matter-file handover | | |

## Decision

- Met criteria:
- Failed criteria:
- Unresolved questions and responsible person:
- Decision and scope of approved use:
- Next review date:

Record “unknown” where evidence is missing. A fluent answer, a citation label or a
saved source is not proof of legal correctness, completeness or current authority.
